Critics Force World’s Two Nicest Chefs, AKA Harold Dieterle And Eric Ripert, Into A Stolen Dish Feud; Fail

As you may or may not have noticed, Harold Dieterle’s The Marrow is in the midst of a review-blitz by critics who have swarmed the restaurant in its fragile, newly opened state. Both Adam Platt and Jay McInerney noticed on their visits that the restaurant’s namesake dish had a familiar feel about it.

Platt noted the “stodgy, ­canoe-size marrowbone, topped, less elegantly than at Le  Bernardin, with smudges of faintly overcooked uni,” while Jay tweeted, “Loved @pete_wells @newyorktimes review of the Marrow, but uni and bone marrow is strictly a ripoff of the great @ericripert.”

Ooh, did Dieterle gank a dish off Le Bernadin’s menu? Are food bloggers everywhere going to convene in their hovels with over-seasoned truffle popcorn to chant “FEUD, FEUD, FEUD” together while watching the Twitterverse explode with the news of this Grave Culinary Diss? Probably not to both. Here’s what:

Eric Ripert is a notoriously zen Buddhist who believes in peace and forgiveness and refuses to talk smack about his fellow chefs. Harold Dieterle is a notoriously dedicated, hard-working-chef-type, who, as Anthony Bourdain once noted, put his head down, put his Top Chef money to good use, and focused on opening restaurants, not fame.

Their responses to the allegations of a stolen dish?

“I said Cheers guys it [i]s the ultimate compliment,” Eric tweeted, adding, “THX for U R support & concern…”

Dieterle told Grub Street: “I was unaware that Chef Ripert offered a similar dish…The brininess of the uni and the richness of the marrow are a great pairing, so I’m not surprised to hear that other chefs have thought of it, too.”

Move along, folks. Nothing to see here.

[Grub Street]

  • KWDragon

    Ah, two adults acting like mature adults. It’s a beautiful thing.

    Can we make some of the other chefs wake up and see the light or the CRAFT(c) of the light, perhaps?

  1. Mediaite
  2. The Mary Sue
  3. RunwayRiot
  4. The Braiser
  5. LawNewz
  6. SportsGrid
  7. Gossip Cop