Sacramento Bee Critic Bashes Dead Chef Don Brown

WATCH: Every Whack-Job Montage From Last Night's MasterChef Auditions

by Mariella Mosthof

MasterChef Season 4 kicked off last night with a two-hour premiere, and, as we look forward to every summer, the kooks came out of the woodwork for the open audition rounds. Of course, those are way more entertaining than the tear-filled, moving stories of overcoming adversity or whatever, so we conveniently compiled all the Crazies Montages in one convenient space for your perusal. You're welcome.

Comments: 0
Lady Chef Stampede: Here's Why Amy Scherber Is The One Baker Ever To Be Profiled In This Column

by Tina Nguyen

This week, on the Lady Chef Stampede, we get baked with Amy Scherber, the woman behind Amy’s Bread. Normally I am deeply suspicious of bakers, regarding them as a mutant offshoot of pastry cooks (if you want to know about pastry cooks, I suggest trying reading some H.P. Lovecraft, who wrote about them in great detail).

Comments: 0
Amy Bouzgalo Served Time In Federal Prison For Social Security Fraud

by Tina Nguyen

In an Arizona Republic article, Jennifer McClellan reports that Bouzgalo formerly went by the name "Amanda Bossingham," and spent 14 months in federal prison in 2008.

Comments: 0
The Braiser Is Hiring Summer Interns!

by Laura Norkin

If you know your Blais from your Bourdain and are passionate about the culture surrounding food; if you can write in a compelling -- if sometimes sarcastic -- tone and wait with bated breath for the James Beards Award announcements and other foodie news, please apply.

Comments: 0

Sacramento Food Critic Bashes Dead Chef In Restaurant Review

by Tina Nguyen 3:45 pm, June 18th

Jay Rayner, the current Don of restaurant critics, noted once that people read bad reviews for delicious schadenfreude at the expense of a chef who dares to think that he’s All That and a bag of crisps. “Take no prisoners” is a great rule to live by as a restaurant critic, except for those times that you forget to do your research and don’t realize that the chef you’re critiquing is dead.

So when Blair Anthony Robertson reviewed local favorite Silva’s Sheldon Inn for the Sacramento Bee and downgraded it to two and a half stars, he did an upstanding job upbraiding the Sacramento mainstay as “likable but not inspiring, with food that is often good but never great.” He specifically referenced the restaurant’s sous chef, Don Brown, in his attempted takedown, ending with him declaring, maybe a bit smugly, that Silva’s was no longer a “dining destination.”

The only problem was that Brown, the former executive chef at renowned restaurant Biba, had died two years ago of a stroke — a crucial error that Brown’s former colleagues and the Sacramento restaurant community jumped on immediately.

“If Blair had bothered to do the least bit of research, he would have read of Don’s passing on the Silva’s Sheldon Inn website,” wrote local chef Teresa Urkofsky on her Facebook page, followed by over 39 comments agreeing with her. “As painful as this is for Don’s colleagues to read, I can only imagine how excruciating it is for his family to read.”

Robertson immediately posted a mea culpa on the SacBee’s blog, and the editors added a correction to the bottom of the review. ” I feel terrible about the mistake,” Robertson stated, “and will redouble my efforts to make sure errors big or small do not find their way into my work.”

Besides serving as a protip for journalists (Make sure people are alive before you make vast, sweeping statements about them), Robertson’s mistake points towards a bigger question: how is he still hired while things like this are happening to quality restaurant critics?

[h/t Poynter]

Tags:

One thought on “Sacramento Food Critic Bashes Dead Chef In Restaurant Review”

spacegod on June 22, 2012 at 5:11 am said:

The headline in my email notification lists this piece as “Food Critic Bashes Cooking Of Chef, Who is Dead.”

I’m relieved that he was already dead, which makes the cooking of him a little easier to stomach.

Log in to Reply