WATCH: We Break Down Last Night’s Controversial Top Chef Verdict

Who’s feeling a little manic depressive today over the loss of Top Chef’s most sardonic character since Richard Blais: Stephanie Cmar? Answer: everyone. Let’s break down what the flimflam happened last night.

First of all, Nicholas made a dish that looked like hair pulled out of a drain, followed by a grainy panna cotta, which everyone knows is a bullshit dessert to begin with. His drain-hair chicken was actually so offensive that one of last night’s guest judges refused to eat it, and it caused a fight at the dinner table about respecting a person’s work.

Alas, Nicholas had immunity. You know who doesn’t believe in immunity? Jacques Pepin. Jacques Pepin, in fact, is all-too-happy to be the soul-crushing voice of reason and ask if you’d serve your mother that food. He might even suggest that the noble thing to do would be to resign. Did Nicholas resign? Of course not. Did Nicholas’ terrible dishes endanger beautiful, hilarious Stephanie and Shirley? They did. Did Stephanie get sent home unjustly? You bet, and we’re sitting shiva over it. These are dark times, Harry.

Top Chef New Orleans Last Chance Kitchen Episode 10: Emeril Demands Beignets
WATCH: Does Jon Favreau Really Make Top Chef-testants Go Freegan in the French Quarter?
Tonight in Food TV: Top Chef Skills Test with Jacques Pepin

  • Al in SoCal

    So first Nicholas complains .. and complains and complains AND COMPLAINS about Carlos. Then the chef that he looks up to and completely respects asks him to resign and he refuses. Let’s remember that Carlos apologized and never said that Nicholas stole the oven in a mean way – he said it jovially when the judges asked him why it was taking so long to get his food out. He also apologized for not cleaning off the knife. Complain once .. but over and over again then smearing Carlos to everyone in the back – it’s JUST as bad as what Carlos did and without an apology!

    Personally I would never hire him, perhaps eat his food (of course) but not want him as an employee. Love that he considers himself “the nice guy” – in whose book? LOL.

  1. Mediaite
  2. The Mary Sue
  3. RunwayRiot
  4. The Braiser
  5. LawNewz
  6. SportsGrid
  7. Gossip Cop